Researchers at the University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab say they have found the first technical evidence of devices being infected with “zero-click” mercenary spyware through targeted online advertising. In a report published on Thursday, 15 October 2026, they say devices at the international news network Al Jazeera were hit this way with spyware made by Candiru.
The findings are Citizen Lab’s, and the lab calls the technique “AdFection”. It matters because it turns the ordinary machinery of online advertising, the auctions that decide which banner a phone shows, into a way of picking out and hacking individual people. The same lab has also reported Pegasus spyware on the phone of a Belgrade university rector; in the Al Jazeera case, it says, an ad alone was enough.
Latest, 27 October 2026: Reuters sources say Discover-Tech is also the unnamed ad bidder TrendAI found targeting Starlink users. See the 27 October update below.
What Citizen Lab found
The report describes itself as “the first-ever technical demonstration of in-the-wild infection of devices with zero-click mercenary spyware via targeted advertisements.”
“We find with high confidence that devices at international media network Al Jazeera were targeted and infected with Candiru’s mercenary spyware using AdFection,” the lab says.
According to the report, at least 45 devices within Al Jazeera were targeted in a series of zero-click attacks in 2024 and 2025. “Zero-click” means the victim does not have to open a message or click a link for the device to be infected.
The lab says network logs provided by Al Jazeera showed a clear pattern: infected devices first contacted servers linked to an ad company, then a Candiru server that checked the device, before being further profiled and infected.
The company at the centre
At the heart of the report is Discover-Tech, which Citizen Lab describes as an Israel-based company that “presents itself as a legitimate online advertising business.” Citizen Lab says it is in fact a bridge between mercenary spyware firms and the advertising industry, and that it found “no evidence that Discover-Tech was engaged in legitimate advertising activity.”
Discover-Tech operates a platform called Controlium, which the lab calls “a one-stop platform for mercenary spyware firms to infect targets via online ads.” According to the report, Controlium’s users include Candiru, which is “reportedly now owned by US-based Integrity Labs.” Citizen Lab also links the platform to Bindecy, an Israel-based firm specialising in zero-click mobile exploits, and to another surveillance company called Intelos.
Candiru was added to the US Commerce Department’s Entity List for developing spyware used against “government officials, journalists, businesspeople, activists, academics, and embassy workers,” Citizen Lab notes.
How it works, in plain terms
Online ads are usually sold in split-second auctions that share information about the person and device about to see them. Citizen Lab says Discover-Tech used this system to profile users. When someone saw one of its seemingly harmless ads, their ad identifier and IP address were sent to Discover-Tech’s servers. If that person was selected for hacking, the device was sent malicious code that exploited and infected it.
Because the ads themselves did not contain the exploit code, the lab says, the platforms delivering them could not easily see their real purpose.
The scale, and an important caveat
Citizen Lab says it analysed almost four billion bidding records that Discover-Tech had left publicly readable on one of its servers, covering March to June 2026, and that the company’s ads appeared in more than 70,000 mobile apps and more than 120,000 websites in that period. It found that Discover-Tech’s ads “directed millions of devices across dozens of countries to contact their profiling and infection servers.” It says the ads appeared on devices on national-security-sensitive networks, including NATO, the United Nations, the European Parliament, the European Commission and the Council of the EU’s General Secretariat.
But the lab is clear about the limits: “A Discover-Tech ad impression does not in and of itself confirm targeting or infection with spyware.” It says such impressions would at minimum have led to profiling, and calls for urgent investigation. Its view of Discover-Tech’s activity is also incomplete: the data comes from one of the company’s platforms and covers a limited period.
It is not clear which governments were behind the attacks, TechCrunch reported Citizen Lab as saying.
Google and IAB Europe cut Discover-Tech off after the investigation
Citizen Lab says that as a result of its investigation, Google and IAB Europe, the advertising industry body, removed Discover-Tech from their ad vendor lists, and Google and Beeswax cut off its access to their ad systems. Vungle (Liftoff) paused the company’s access while it reviews it, and Eskimi blocked its accounts and domains, the report says. Until then, Citizen Lab says, Discover-Tech had sat on Google’s lists of certified ad vendors and on IAB Europe’s Global Vendor List from 2020, and used IAB Europe’s Transparency and Consent Framework to process GDPR consent signals for users in Europe.
Discover-Tech and Candiru did not answer Citizen Lab
Discover-Tech did not respond to Citizen Lab’s request for comment within its deadline, and neither did Candiru/Integrity Labs, Bindecy or Intelos, according to the report. TechCrunch reported that Discover-Tech and Al Jazeera did not respond to its requests for comment, and that Integrity Labs could not be reached.
Citizen Lab’s advice: turn off ad tracking if you may be a target
Bill Marczak, a senior researcher at Citizen Lab, told TechCrunch: “If you might be targeted based on who you are or what you do, it’s time to disable ad tracking on your devices or even block ads altogether.” He called Discover-Tech “surely just the tip of the iceberg.”
Update, 27 October 2026: Sources tie Discover-Tech to heavy bidding on Starlink users
Discover-Tech was also the leading bidder for ads shown to users of SpaceX’s Starlink satellite internet service in more than 100 countries, and the ads were likely being used to locate or otherwise watch them, six people familiar with the matter told Reuters. The finding comes from advertising-auction data, not a breach of Starlink’s network.
The data was published on 15 October, the same day as Citizen Lab’s report, by TrendAI, a unit of Tokyo-based Trend Micro, whose Zero Day Initiative also handles bug reports for software makers. TrendAI’s report never names the company. It describes an ad-tech entity it calls “Shadow-Earth-79”, which it says is “the number one bidder in 105 individual countries in Starlink traffic that we observed” and accounts for “approximately 13% of all winning bid events in Starlink traffic, five times higher than average (approximately 3%) bids for other bidders”. The six sources told Reuters that Shadow-Earth-79 is TrendAI’s codename for Discover-Tech.
TrendAI says several of those countries, including Syria, Sudan, Myanmar and Libya, ban or restrict Starlink, and that the entity was also the top ad buyer in Syria, Libya, Yemen and South Sudan. It concludes with “moderate-to-high confidence” that the operation works as “targeting and tracking infrastructure rather than a commercial advertising operation”. Its data covers a single demand-side platform. In the UK, its tables list Shadow-Earth-79 among the top five bidders on Starlink traffic, with 314 of 3,338 observed bids.
According to Reuters, TrendAI’s researchers discussed naming Discover-Tech but dropped the idea after executives raised legal concerns, five of the sources said. TrendAI said in a statement that its approach was aimed at reducing the risk of mistakes and avoiding “hype-driven labels”. SpaceX did not respond to Reuters, and Discover-Tech and its chief executive gave no response over two weeks. Reuters also reported that at least one large US technology company and one international organisation have opened internal inquiries into whether Discover-Tech’s ads targeted their staff.
The Starlink findings are separate from the Candiru attacks described above: neither TrendAI nor the sources linked the two. What they share is the route. Ad auctions can hand bidders details such as a device’s IP address and network, which is enough to tell a satellite user from a mobile one. Citizen Lab’s advice to people at risk, to turn off ad tracking or block ads, applies equally here; TrendAI also suggests resetting advertising IDs and using modes such as iPhone Lockdown Mode. Starlink’s growth, including deals such as Starlink Mobile’s 11 million VEON customers, means more people in remote or restricted places now reach the internet over satellite links that ad bidders can recognise.
Candiru’s ad route shows the ad industry’s checks were built for fraud, not spies
The most uncomfortable part of the Citizen Lab report is not the spyware, which is familiar, but how ordinary the delivery was. Discover-Tech did not need to break into an ad network. By the lab’s account it bought its way in, passed the vendor checks that Google and IAB Europe run, and then used the data every bidder receives in an auction to decide which phones to profile and which to hand to Candiru. The industry’s vetting is designed to catch advertisers who fake clicks or misuse consent. It was not designed to ask whether a supposed advertiser has any customers at all, and the lab found almost no sign of real advertising in Discover-Tech’s records.
That also explains why the Al Jazeera case is hard to defend against at the level of the individual. A journalist can refuse to open suspicious links. They cannot easily refuse to see a banner in a weather app. The defences that do help sit with the platforms and regulators: stricter checks on who may bid, less personal data in each bid request, and enforcement of the consent rules that Discover-Tech used to look compliant. European privacy regulators already handle complaints about tracking, such as noyb’s GDPR complaints over Scale AI’s Outlier, and the lab has asked regulators to examine whether Discover-Tech and Candiru broke the law. The reassuring part is that the research worked: once Google and others saw the evidence, the vendor lost much of its access before the report was even published. The open question is how many similar firms are still on the lists.
Three points from the Citizen Lab report
- Ads as a delivery route. Citizen Lab says it has shown spyware being delivered through ordinary targeted advertising, without a click.
- Wide exposure, unclear infection. Ads reached sensitive networks, but an ad impression alone doesn’t prove anyone was infected.
- Higher-risk users can act. Citizen Lab advises turning off ad tracking or blocking ads.
Sources
- Citizen Lab, “How Discover-Tech turned targeted ads into a pipeline for spyware”, 15 October 2026
- Citizen Lab, “Exposing AdFection: Executive Summary”, 15 October 2026
- TechCrunch, “Citizen Lab says governments are abusing online ads to hack people with ‘zero-click’ spyware”, 15 October 2026
- Reuters (via Al-Monitor), “Exclusive-Alleged Israeli spy company heavily targeted Starlink users, sources say”, Raphael Satter, 27 October 2026
- TrendAI Research, “Invasive Ads: The Unconventional Cyber Surveillance Attack Surface”, 15 October 2026
Get TSN’s biggest tech stories, explained.
News and insights across AI, tech, crypto and cybersecurity. Every source linked. Unsubscribe anytime.
Get the newsletterRelated stories
- Microsoft Disrupts Three Chinese-Language Phishing Services It Links to More Than One Billion Scam Messages
- Pegasus Spyware Hit Belgrade’s Rector Days Before Serbia Votes, Citizen Lab Says
- Trend Micro’s ZDI Sent Unpatched Linux Kernel Flaws to Public Lists
Follow @tsnmediahub on X for breaking AI news as it happens.
Follow on X

