The Investigatory Powers Tribunal has confirmed that the Home Secretary has given Apple a technical capability notice under section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. In an OPEN judgment issued on 19 November 2026, after a hearing on 17 September, the panel said: “We reject the respondent’s contention that it would be damaging to national security to confirm the fact that the respondent has given Apple a technical capability notice.” The tribunal has not ruled on whether the notice was lawful, and it has not disclosed the notice’s contents. The IPT’s page URL still uses a slug that names an unrelated earlier case; the page title and the accompanying PDF are this Apple judgment, [2026] UKIPTrib 9.
In brief
- The tribunal has confirmed the fact that the Home Office gave Apple a technical capability notice. Lady Carmichael, the president, sat with Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson.
- The judgment leaves the lawfulness of the notice, and how much of its detail can be aired, for later. Liberty says a final hearing is expected in 2027.
- Liberty puts UK iCloud use at an estimated 40 million people, and on the same page cites a Which? estimate of about 39 to 40 million. Neither figure comes from the government or from Apple.
The tribunal confirmed the technical capability notice, not its contents
The decision covers two joined matters: Apple Inc’s claim against the Secretary of State for the Home Department (IPT/26/191/CH) and the claim by Privacy International, Liberty, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner (IPT/25/83-86/CH). Both raise the secretary of state’s power to give a “relevant operator” a technical capability notice under section 253. The government had argued that it would damage national security if she were required to confirm or deny, in public, whether such a notice had been given to Apple.
The panel rejected that argument on the fact of the notice itself. It then drew a line under the detail. “The extent, if at all, to which some of the detail of the technical capability notice may be disclosed without damaging national security or the public interest is better addressed separately, after disclosure of evidence and when the precise issues to be determined at the hearing are clear.” In a preceding passage, the tribunal also referred to “extensive (but unacknowledged) departures from NCND” — the government’s neither-confirm-nor-deny policy — and said authorised confirmations had already reached newspapers and foreign officials.
Privacy International called the judgment “a major victory for transparency and effective oversight.” Caroline Wilson Palow, its legal director, said the government “should not be allowed to use its policy of ‘neither confirm nor deny’ as an impenetrable shield.” Those are campaigning assessments. The legal finding is narrower: the fact of the notice can now be stated in the OPEN proceedings. What the notice requires Apple to do remains, on the tribunal’s own terms, a question for later.
Liberty describes technical capability notices as orders that can require companies to change products to facilitate surveillance, including by removing or weakening encryption, and says companies are legally prevented from revealing that they have received one. Press reporting, which the judgment itself summarises, has long described a notice said to require access to users’ data in decrypted form. None of that reporting is converted into a tribunal finding about the contents. Until the panel says otherwise, the only official confirmation is that a notice was given.
A confirmation is not a verdict on the Investigatory Powers Act
The next date that matters is the one Liberty has flagged: a final hearing expected in 2027. That is when the lawfulness of the regime, and of this notice, is due to be argued. Today’s judgment is a case-management outcome on secrecy, not a ruling that the secretary of state acted lawfully or unlawfully.
The 40 million figure should be handled with the same care. It is Liberty’s estimate of UK iCloud users, with a Which? range of about 39 to 40 million cited on the same page. It is not a count of people shown to be affected by this notice, and it is not an Apple or Home Office number. How many accounts, if any, sit inside the still-undisclosed terms of the notice is unknown.
TSN has no earlier post on a technical capability notice, so the nearest context is other UK investigatory-powers oversight. The Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office recently reported that GCHQ could not account for thousands of items of removable media, an IPCO finding about holdings rather than a notice to a company. The opening of the National Cyber Force headquarters in Lancashire and the UK and France Pall Mall Process industry guidelines sit in the same government-and-intelligence neighbourhood, but they are not TCN cases. The test of this judgment will be how much of the Apple notice is allowed into OPEN in time for that 2027 hearing.
Get TSN’s biggest tech stories, explained.
News and insights across AI, tech, crypto and cybersecurity. Every source linked. Unsubscribe anytime.
Get the newsletterRelated stories
- GCHQ Cannot Account for Thousands of Removable Media, IPCO Says is the closest recent TSN account of official oversight under the investigatory-powers regime, and the right next stop for that file.
- The King Opens the National Cyber Force HQ in Lancashire
- UK and France Issue Pall Mall Process Industry Guidelines
Sources
- Investigatory Powers Tribunal, Apple Inc and others v Secretary of State for the Home Department, [2026] UKIPTrib 9, 19 November 2026 (the page URL slug names an unrelated earlier case; the title and PDF are this judgment)
- OPEN judgment PDF, [2026] UKIPTrib 9
- Liberty, 19 November 2026
- Privacy International, 19 November 2026
Follow @tsnmediahub on X for breaking AI news as it happens.
Follow on X

